• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Fair Play For Women

Fair Play For Women

  • Prison
  • Sport
  • GRA
  • Language
  • Changing rooms
  • Resources ▼
    • Take action! Here’s how
    • Key facts
    • UK law
    • Science
    • Sex vs gender
    • Consultation submissions
    • Materials
  • About Us ▼
    • Review of 2021
    • Our aim
    • Our beliefs
    • Our spokeswoman
    • Our history and achievements
    • Our supporters
    • News
      • Newspapers
      • TV Interviews
      • Radio interviews
    • Contact
    • Donate
You are here: Home / Judicial Review / Scottish Government In Court on 2nd February Over Unlawful Definition of “Sex” In Census

Scottish Government In Court on 2nd February Over Unlawful Definition of “Sex” In Census

18th January 2022 by FPFW

The Scottish Government must go to court to defend its decision to change the meaning of “Sex” in the Scottish Census.

The Court of Session in Edinburgh has accepted Fair Play For Women’s petition for a judicial review into the guidance accompanying the ‘sex question’ on the Scottish Census and has set a hearing for February 2nd.

Fair Play For Women has instructed top Scottish Advocate Roddy Dunlop QC, Dean of Faculty of Advocates.

National Records of Scotland (NRS) operates the Scottish Census under the leadership of the Registrar General for Scotland; the Guidance was published with the knowledge and approval of the Scottish Government.

The unlawful Scottish guidance includes the fact that people may self-identify when answering the sex question in the census. It says “If you are transgender the answer you give can be different from what is on your birth certificate. You do not need a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC)”. 

The English High Court ordered similar guidance produced by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) to be taken down just days before Census Day for England and Wales in March 2021.

Dr Nicola Williams, Director of Fair Play For Women, said:

“There is now a separate question specifically for transgender people to register their identity in the Census. There is no need to answer the question about sex with a gender identity too”.

The Census Act 1920 is a Westminster statute with application across Scotland, England, and Wales. The 1920 Act permits the holding of censuses and includes “sex” as one piece of information that must be asked. In its petition for judicial review Fair Play For Women argues that:

“What is meant by “sex” in the 1920 Act is a matter of statutory interpretation, and as such a question of law. There is no provision currently recognised in law that permits any form of self-identification to affect one’s legally registered sex.”

“the Guidance authorises and approves conduct which could amount to an offence under the 1920 Act. The Guidance is therefore unlawful and should be reduced as sought by the petitioner”.

National Records for Scotland have so far refused to withdraw the guidance insisting it is not unlawful and ignoring the findings of the High Court earlier this year.

“NRS consider that the published guidance relating to Scotland’s Census 2022 in its current terms is not unlawful, and that the section relating to the question of “what is your sex” will not be withdrawn and re-worded.”

Dr Nicola Williams, Director of Fair Play For Women, said:

“There are huge differences between males and females in the UK, in critical areas such as crime statistics. That’s why accurate recording of sex matters. The High Court in England backed our position and we are confident that the Scottish court will see it the same way.”

“The ONS wasted over a hundred thousand of pounds of tax payers money in a desperate attempt to defend their unlawful position in court. It is beyond belief that the Scottish Government is now repeating this reckless act and forcing ordinary members of the public to go to court once again”.

“Extreme gender ideology is deeply embedded within the Scottish Government, and promoted at the highest levels including the First Minister. Winning this action will constrain the Scottish Ministers’ pursuit of their ideologically-driven agenda with no regard for Scottish women or long-standing UK laws. Pressing on with an unlawful definition of sex in the Census is a political act that is particularly harmful to women and girls in Scotland. We will not standby as the meaning of sex is erased”.

The NRS has defended its decision by saying  “This guidance is the same as that discussed with the Parliament when the census legislation was agreed.  However, in 2019 Scottish Minister, Fiona Hyslop had placed an amendment before the Scottish Parliament to expand sex to include “and gender identity” but was ultimately unsuccessful.

During pre-legislative scrutiny the parliamentary committee said “the way the term ‘gender identity’ has been used in the Bill has created confusion and a perception that “sex” is being conflated with “gender identity”. It was removed from the bill leaving the mandatory sex question unchanged. The NRS has recently confirmed “there is no intention to introduce further legislation for the 2022 Census”.

Dr Nicola Williams said:

“What is meant by “sex” is a question of law – and not simply a matter on which the Scottish Ministers can simply take a view. If Nicola Sturgeon wanted to change the definition of sex in the Scottish Census she should have convinced her own parliament its the right thing to do. Her Ministers tried but failed to do so”.

“She does not have the power to make up her own definition and force it through regardless. That’s not how democracy works. We are bringing this legal action to defend the rights of women and girls in Scotland”.

In addition to the longstanding question “What is your sex?” the Scottish Census will, for the first time, have a separate question that asks  “do you consider yourself to be trans, or have a trans history?”

Nicola Williams said:

“I welcome the addition of a new and discrete question about transgender identity. The trans community should be counted and that information is important and useful. Accurate data on sex is also important, particularly for women and girls. There is no good reason why both questions should be used to record gender identity.”

“Sex and gender identity are different characteristics and should not be conflated in data collection. Everyone has a sex in law, including transgender people and both piece of information should be captured by the Census”.

/END

For more information go to https://fairplayforwomen.com/fair-play-for-women-launches-judicial-review-over-sex-question-in-scottish-census/

 

Your donation will support our work

Filed Under: Data, Judicial Review, Scottish GRA reforms

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Biological sex
  • Children
  • Gender Identity
  • Male violence
  • Scottish GRA reforms
  • Silencing women
  • Policy guidance

Our materials

  • Our factsheets
  • Our short films and animations
  • Our memes
  • Our research

Our latest articles

  • Take Action: Say NO to letting Sex Self-ID in through the back door.
  • Women’s cycling race saved after campaigns raise public support
  • How transgender inclusion leads to female exclusion
  • Sex-based rights groups make formal bid to sponsor women’s cycle race
  • Write to the people who govern your sport

Archives

Footer

Prisons, crime and protecting women

  • The facts about transgender prisoners
  • Karen White & prison review
  • Sex attacks in female prisons
  • Female inmate suing the government
  • Refuge shelters deeply worried
  • How do women in prison feel about sharing with transgender prisoners?
  • Can you believe what you read about sexual and violent crimes?
  • Factsheets

Sport and the human body

  • Biological sex differences
  • Chromosomes, sex and gender
  • Guidelines for single-sex sport policy
  • A scientist reviews the IOC’s transgender inclusion policy
  • The science and statistics behind the transgender debate
  • Safeguarding in sport still matters
  • Testosterone reduction policies
  • Rachel McKinnon transwoman cyclist
  • You can help

Making policy and the law

  • The Equality Act 2010 and women’s rights
  • GRA reform
  • Advice and guidance for policy makers
  • Equality impact analysis advice
  • Public Sector Equality Duty
  • Changing room policy advice
  • Scottish Government omits women’s evidence
  • The Scottish bill that stole the word woman
  • What can I do now?

© 2022 · Fair Play For Women

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt out if you wish. Read More

Accept Decline Cookie Settings
I consent to the use of following cookies:
Cookie Declaration About Cookies
Necessary (2) Marketing (1) Analytics (4) Preferences (0) Unclassified (4)
Necessary cookies help make a website usable by enabling basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website. The website cannot function properly without these cookies.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
wpl_user_preference fairplayforwomen.com WP GDPR Cookie Consent Preferences 1 year HTTP
YSC youtube.com YouTube session cookie. 52 years HTTP
Marketing cookies are used to track visitors across websites. The intention is to display ads that are relevant and engaging for the individual user and thereby more valuable for publishers and third party advertisers.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE youtube.com YouTube cookie. 6 months HTTP
Analytics cookies help website owners to understand how visitors interact with websites by collecting and reporting information anonymously.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
_ga fairplayforwomen.com Google Universal Analytics long-time unique user tracking identifier. 2 years HTTP
_gid fairplayforwomen.com Google Universal Analytics short-time unique user tracking identifier. 1 days HTTP
vuid vimeo.com Vimeo tracking cookie 2 years HTTP
IDE doubleclick.net Google advertising cookie used for user tracking and ad targeting purposes. 2 years HTTP
Preference cookies enable a website to remember information that changes the way the website behaves or looks, like your preferred language or the region that you are in.
We do not use cookies of this type.
Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
_gat_UA-109881507-1 fairplayforwomen.com --- Session ---
GASessionCookie fairplayforwomen.com --- Session ---
rtc linkedin.com --- Session ---
_wpfuuid fairplayforwomen.com --- 11 years ---
Cookies are small text files that can be used by websites to make a user's experience more efficient. The law states that we can store cookies on your device if they are strictly necessary for the operation of this site. For all other types of cookies we need your permission. This site uses different types of cookies. Some cookies are placed by third party services that appear on our pages.
Cookie Settings