• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Fair Play For Women

Fair Play For Women

  • Prison
  • Sport
  • GRA
  • Language
  • Changing rooms
  • Resources ▼
    • Take action! Here’s how
    • Key facts
    • UK law
    • Science
    • Sex vs gender
    • Consultation submissions
    • Materials
  • About Us ▼
    • Review of 2022
    • Our aim
    • Our beliefs
    • Our spokeswoman
    • Our history and achievements
    • Our supporters
    • News
      • Newspapers
      • TV Interviews
      • Radio interviews
    • Contact
    • Donate
You are here: Home / Children / Could do better. The EHRC should rewrite its draft guidance.

Could do better. The EHRC should rewrite its draft guidance.

30th August 2019 by FPFW

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has been working on new guidance for schools on pupils with the protected characteristic of gender reassignment since 2017. There has been limited consultation. On Aug 29 a draft version of the guidance was leaked onto the internet. This is the first time we have been able to see it. The following is a short overview of the major problems we have seen with the current draft.

 

1) SECRETS AND LIES

The draft guidance suggests that schools should, if requested, keep a child’s sex secret from teachers and other pupils, and collude in lying about their sex. 

“A group of pupils go on a school trip …the school considers the age group, privacy risks from sharing tents and the lack of awareness that the pupil is trans…. The trans pupil is satisfied that her trans status will not be disclosed by the arrangements.  “ (page 27)

“School should not give the vaccination to a trans girl but should make suitable arrangements so that, if her birth sex is not widely known, it is not inadvertently revealed.” (page 29). 

Recommendations that suggest a school should agree to allow a children to enter the school with their sex kept secret are found throughout the EHRC draft guidance, but the question of whether this is appropriate is never discussed. This practice has safeguarding implications. Telling children to lie or keep secrets about sex puts them at risk of abuse. Keeping secrets isolates children from their peers and from sources of support. 

The Equality Act does not require this. An inclusive and responsible approach would be for a school to agree with a child and their parents a form of words to use that explains honestly and sensitively that this child would like to be treated socially as a boy or a girl, but that their sex has not changed. 


2) PUSHING GIRLS OUT OF THEIR OWN CHANGING ROOMS

The draft guidance says that male children who identify as girls should be allowed to use girls’ changing rooms and toilets. It suggests that if female children feel uncomfortable in this circumstance, they should be offered the choice of using a separate changing room (such as the disabled facilities). 

“trans boys and trans girls can use the single-sex facilities that align with their gender identity if they wish to do so, A trans girl pupil opts to use the girls’ changing room, and most of her fellow pupils are happy with this arrangement. However, one pupil is uncomfortable with this arrangement, so chooses to use the private changing room instead.” ( page 15)

This is not what the Equality Act or existing EHRC technical guidance says. Girls and boys over the age of 8 should be able to change, wash and go to the toilet with privacy from the opposite sex.  An inclusive and responsible approach would be to make accessible changing facilities available for any child that does not want to change with children of their own sex, not to force girls out of their own changing room. 

NB: The Scottish government has withdrawn LGBT youth schools guidance which makes this recommendation because the “the approach risks potentially excluding other girls from female-only spaces. That cannot be right.” 


3) UNDERMINING FREEDOM OF THOUGHT AND SPEECH

The guidance says teachers and other pupils must describe a male child as “she” and a female child as “he” ( or use ‘non-binary’ pronouns like ze, zir).  It says that “appropriate steps” should be taken if a person refuses. 

“If a pupil has legally changed their name, then the school must use the pupil’s new name and relevant pronoun.” (page 19)

“Concerns about repeated or deliberate use of a previous name or pronoun should be investigated and appropriate steps taken to address the issue” (page 20)

There is no law about using pronouns. This could be challenged as compelled speech, infringing on the right to freedom of belief of other pupils and teachers. It is not clear what “appropriate steps” the EHRC is suggesting, but if it says the school ‘must’ use preferred pronouns, this suggests a teacher could lose their job, or a child be expelled, for not complying.

4) NO MORE ALL FEMALE  SPORTS

The guidance says that schools cannot apply a ‘blanket policy’ of offering female only sports teams or sport competitions. 

“If considering excluding a trans pupil as a competitor, schools should consider on a case-by-case basis objective evidence about whether inclusion would result in unfair competition”

“Schools should consider ways of enabling all pupils to participate in sports, including competitive events that align with their gender identity” (p24)

This is not what the Equality Act says. Single-sex sports are allowed for fairness and safety. Sports are not segregated by gender identity.  ‘Case-by-case’ assessments are not fair on anyone. It is not fair on female pupils to allow some males into female sports, and it is not fair to put pressure on transgender pupils as they are going through puberty. It would be fairer and more inclusive for schools to maintain single-sex sports for age groups where this is justified, and to make clear that sex and gender identity are not the same thing. Children who identify as  transgender should be welcome to compete in sports with children of the same sex and should not be bullied.

5) PUTTING SINGLE-SEX SCHOOLS IN DOUBT

The  leaked draft guidance says that a singl-sex school is likely to be discriminating if it does not admit pupils of the opposite sex who identify as transgender (i.e. treat a female child as if they were a boy and allow them into an all-boys school on that basis). 

“The school is likely to be discriminating against the trans pupil unless it can demonstrate its decision is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.”(page 33)

“To meet the needs of and avoid disadvantage to trans pupils, schools should take a case-by-case approach to admission requests by trans pupils.”(page 33)

This is not what the Equality Act says. Single-sex schools are allowed by law to have a policy of only admitting children of a single sex (regardless of whether they identify as transgender). This does not require individual case-by-case assessment. Putting a child into a single-sex school of the opposite sex would lock them into a decision, making it difficult to explore their identity and their options as they grow up. A single-sex school cannot safely and fairly accommodate a child living as if they were a member of the opposite sex in sports, changing rooms, school trips etc

CONCLUSION

None of these problematic recommendations are required by the Equality Act 2010. They create problems of discrimination for other groups, and health, safety and safeguarding risks for both children who identify as transgender and their peers.

The Women and Equalities Select Committee report on the Equality Act stated “We do not believe that non-statutory guidance will be sufficient to bring the clarity needed  [on single and separate sex services]. We recommend that, in the absence of case law the EHRC develop, and the Secretary of State lay before Parliament, a dedicated Code of Practice.”

THE EHRC should not be publishing any more non-statutory guidance until government has responded to the WESC recommendations that PARLIAMENTARY-APPROVED guidance is needed.

If you are concerned about this write to Liz Truss (Minister for Women and Equalities), Gavin Williamson (Secretary of State for Education) and David Isaac (Chair of the EHRC).

Filed Under: Children, Law

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Biological sex
  • Children
  • Gender Identity
  • Male violence
  • Scottish GRA reforms
  • Silencing women
  • Policy guidance

Our materials

  • Our factsheets
  • Our short films and animations
  • Our memes
  • Our research

Our latest articles

  • British Cycling bows to the inevitable
  • Meeting the United Nations Independent Expert on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity
  • A sign of the turning tide in sport
  • Males can be lawfully excluded from female-only jobs
  • Athletics and swimming restore fair competition for women and girls

Archives

Footer

Prisons, crime and protecting women

  • The facts about transgender prisoners
  • Prisons timeline – how did we get here?
  • Karen White & prison review
  • Sex attacks in female prisons
  • Refuge shelters deeply worried
  • How do women in prison feel about sharing with transgender prisoners?
  • Can you believe what you read about sexual and violent crimes?
  • The judicial review of prisons policy
  • Factsheets

Sport and the human body

  • A progress report on the fight to restore fairness in female sport
  • Sport timeline: how did we get here?
  • Biological sex differences
  • Chromosomes, sex and gender
  • The science and statistics behind the transgender debate
  • Testosterone suppression in “elite athletes” – what do we know?
  • Safeguarding in sport still matters
  • Male inclusion leads to female exclusion
  • What you can do

Making policy and the law

  • Scottish government is forcing sex self-ID on whole of UK.
  • The Equality Act 2010 and women’s rights
  • GRA reform
  • Advice and guidance for policy makers
  • Changing room policy advice
  • What can I do now?
  • Take Action: Say NO to letting Sex Self-ID in through the back door.
  • Public opinion on the tension between women’s rights and trans demands

© 2023 · Fair Play For Women

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt out if you wish. Read More

Accept Decline Cookie Settings
I consent to the use of following cookies:
Cookie Declaration About Cookies
Necessary (2) Marketing (1) Analytics (4) Preferences (0) Unclassified (4)
Necessary cookies help make a website usable by enabling basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website. The website cannot function properly without these cookies.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
wpl_user_preference fairplayforwomen.com WP GDPR Cookie Consent Preferences 1 year HTTP
YSC youtube.com YouTube session cookie. 52 years HTTP
Marketing cookies are used to track visitors across websites. The intention is to display ads that are relevant and engaging for the individual user and thereby more valuable for publishers and third party advertisers.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE youtube.com YouTube cookie. 6 months HTTP
Analytics cookies help website owners to understand how visitors interact with websites by collecting and reporting information anonymously.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
_ga fairplayforwomen.com Google Universal Analytics long-time unique user tracking identifier. 2 years HTTP
_gid fairplayforwomen.com Google Universal Analytics short-time unique user tracking identifier. 1 days HTTP
vuid vimeo.com Vimeo tracking cookie 2 years HTTP
IDE doubleclick.net Google advertising cookie used for user tracking and ad targeting purposes. 2 years HTTP
Preference cookies enable a website to remember information that changes the way the website behaves or looks, like your preferred language or the region that you are in.
We do not use cookies of this type.
Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
Name Domain Purpose Expiry Type
_gat_UA-109881507-1 fairplayforwomen.com --- Session ---
GASessionCookie fairplayforwomen.com --- Session ---
rtc linkedin.com --- Session ---
_wpfuuid fairplayforwomen.com --- 11 years ---
Cookies are small text files that can be used by websites to make a user's experience more efficient. The law states that we can store cookies on your device if they are strictly necessary for the operation of this site. For all other types of cookies we need your permission. This site uses different types of cookies. Some cookies are placed by third party services that appear on our pages.
Cookie Settings